Sunday, July 21, 2013

A Tale of Two Educational Games


A couple of years ago, I spent a summer teaching English in Ankara, Turkey. When I arrived, I could say two things in Turkish: “Hello,” and “Is there any bread?” I had brought a couple of English-language books with me, but eventually, I finished them, and greetings-and-baked-goods-based literature was in low supply. During my irregular skype calls home, I noticed that I was having trouble finding English words other than the simple vocabulary I used with my students. I worried that I was going to lose my English. So I was happy to discover “Word Bubbles,” an online video game which promised to increase my vocabulary.

The game works as follows: you are given a string of three letters, and you have one minute to come up with as many English words as you can that start with that string. I played it for a while, sometimes alone, sometimes with a student to test her English-word-generating speed. After a while, though, I realized that it was doing absolutely nothing for my vocabulary. The more you play it, the faster you get at coming up with the same words, but you never learn any new ones. If, instead, at the end of each round, a few new words were shown, you might actually learn something. As it is, “Word Bubbles” is the perfect example of a purportedly educational game which teaches you absolutely nothing.

On the other hand, “Lyrics Training” is a fun educational game that I've been recommending non-stop for the past two years. On the Lyrics Training website, there are a ridiculous number of music videos in different languages. You play the music video, and the lyrics appear underneath, but with words missing. You have to fill in the blanks to get the music video to proceed. Depending on how difficult you want to make it, you can set it so 10% of the words are missing, 25% are missing, or everything is blank. As of today, there are music videos in English, Spanish, French, German, Portuguese, Italian and Dutch. You can search by artist or song title, or just by genre or difficulty level. People load new videos every day, so there is always new stuff to try.

Unfortunately, I've found it difficult to use it in a classroom setting. If the students are at very different levels of English (or German, Spanish, etc) comprehension, then either only a couple of them will participate, or the ones with more advanced language skills will get bored while waiting for the beginners to figure a word out. However, it could be a great activity for a single student, or a group of four or fewer, if they finish an activity more than five minutes before the rest of the class. It's also something I recommend to a lot of my students to keep up with their English over the summer. Because there are a lot of popular songs on the site, it's something the students really enjoy, so unlike a lot of optional assignments, they actually do it.

It's a great game because you can read the lyrics along with the video, so you can pick up words you might otherwise have missed. Since they're written out, they're very easy to look up in a dictionary. You can play the same song as many times as you want, until you have memorized it. Memorizing songs is wonderful, because you remember words and grammatical structures much easier when they're in context. You also get to hear different accents, comparing a Spanish singer's pronunciation with that of a Mexican singer. One word of warning, though: You will almost certainly get some of the songs stuck in your head!

4 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This game sounds really interesting! The fact that it uses music to help bolster learning is really clever. It makes me think about how quickly kids can memorize song lyrics and movie quotes while they struggle to retain what they learn in school. This game seems to take advantage of this in a learning environment.

    One potential concern popped into my mind while I was reading your post. What about the many misuses of grammar in song lyrics? Songwriters often sacrifice proper grammar and sentence structure for rhythm and rhyme. What happens if students learn improper grammar from this game? Have you ever seen an example of this in your experiences?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's a good point, Erin. I will have to start pointing this concern out when I recommend the site. Pop music a good way to learn *informal* grammar. For example, through pop music, I learned that infinitives in German are often shortened, so "gehen" becomes "gehn", and "haben" becomes "habm" or just "ham." Learning this makes it much easier to understand spoken informal German. But I have to remember *not* to speak this way when I'm speaking to someone formally.

      Another problem I didn't address in the blog is when there are flat-out errors in the lyrics. I'm not sure what the vetting process is for posting on that site. My guess is that this problem arises when people post lyrics to songs that aren't in their native language. Still, the acuracy is high enough that I think it's still a great game.

      Delete
  3. I agree with you, Naomi, that learning lyrics to a song in another language can be beneficial to learning about that language. Because music is so influential, having an understanding of the slang and nuances in a song will surely help one learn the language more fully. My wife has always told me that she would listen to German music to better understand slang and pronunciations while studying German because it gave her more insight to the culture that couldn't be provided through a text book. It is important to keep in mind that slang will most likely be present in the music lyrics, but that further enables the student to better understand the cultural context of the song and lyrics.

    ReplyDelete